Success Academy Fails (again) To Report Regents Scores

About a year ago I found myself in a snafu of red tape as I attempted to track down the high school test results for the famed Success Academy Charter School Network.  Though Success Academy is known for its stellar 3-8 Math and ELA test scores in New York State, much less is known about how students perform after 8th grade.

One reason for this is that most of the Success Academy schools only have younger students.  Of the schools that do have the upper grades, the number of students in each grade is very small because of attrition and Success Academy’s refusal to ‘backfill’ student who leave with other eager students from their mythical waiting list.

The oldest Success Academy students began the school known as Success Academy Harlem I in 2006 as first graders.  At that time there were 73 students in the class of 2018.  By 2015 those 73 first graders had dwindled to just 20 tenth graders, down from 26 ninth graders the year before.  How many of those 20 students are currently 11th graders in Success Academy is unknown to the public, though that data does get released sometime next year.  It’s a safe bet to say that the number of eleventh graders right now is somewhere in the teens.

High School students in New York State take standardized final exams known as ‘The Regents.’  Students must take these Regents exams to graduate.  The ‘college ready’ statistic is based on these Regents exams, and schools are judged on how well their students do on these tests.

Last year I noticed that unlike the other charter schools, there was no data for the Regents scores at Success Academy on the New York State public data site.  I emailed the data department of the state and they said they did not have the data, that Success Academy did not report any data, and that if I want to know those scores my best bet would be to simply call Success Academy and ask them for the scores  — something I did not try, though it would have made for an amusing telephone conversation.

The other day I checked the data site again to see if the newly posted 2016 Regents scores were available for Success Academy.  Again I found no data available.  Again I emailed one of the people at the data center for the state.  Again they said that Success Academy did not report their results.  But this time they provided some new information in their email:

NYSED Helpdesk Team (New York State Education Department)

Dec 7, 1:59 PM EST


Thank you for reaching out to our Data Support help desk again for this same request.  The school you have inquired about did not submit their Regent’s data on time.  They will have an opportunity, as all schools do, to correct their data when the Level 0 Historical application opens in 2017.  Corrected or missing data submitted through this application is not updated on our public data site as the information posted is from the data set submitted on time and made available to the public at that time.  Therefore you will not see their data on the public data site (

In addition, when people who are related to the press want data requests they are to be submitted to our Communications Office.

This ticket will be closed.

In some other reality I could imagine that this data person would be grateful that I identified a giant missing data point and they would be thanking me for noticing it, and basically doing their job for them for free.  Instead they are telling me that even if they do get the data from Success Academy they will not update their databases with that information anyway.  So basically any school can avoid having their Regents scores published publicly by conveniently missing the first deadline.

So then I wondered if maybe the 2015 scores, the ones I couldn’t get last year, were maybe available somewhere and the communications office could supply them.  So I called the phone number they gave me (there was no email address so there is no paper trail about what I’m about to describe).  I explained that I was a teacher who was looking for Success Academy’s Regents scores from 2015.  They told me that they didn’t have access to any data so they were confused why I would be calling them.  I told them that I was referred to them by the data person and then the communications person suggested that I simply call Success Academy to ask them for the missing scores.  I said that it was unlikely for Success Academy to provide the scores to me and the communications person took my contact information and said she would get back to me.

I’m inclined to believe that the state is not part of a conspiracy to cover up embarrassing test scores for Success Academy.  But the state does not seem overly concerned with the fact that they are not getting the Regents scores from them.  Another possibility, and this would be a pretty big scandal, I think, if this is the case, perhaps students at Success Academy don’t even take Regents exams.  Maybe part of their flexibility in their charter does not require it.

The strange thing about Success Academy debates is that this is a school that exists right now and not just in the abstract.  There is a group of between 1 and 20 students who wake up each day and attend the eleventh grade at Success Academy Harlem I.  There are also a bunch of teachers who teach those kids and surely the number of ‘degrees of separation’ between me, or any teacher in the city really, and those teachers and students is likely less than three.  Yet something as simple as finding out how those students performed on a standardized test — the bread and butter of the Success Academy empire is something tjat seems as elusive as finding out the meaning of Stonehenge or how the Pyramids were constructed.

If I learn more details about the mysterious Success Academy Regents scores, I will update this post with them.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Success Academy Fails (again) To Report Regents Scores

  1. john fager says:

    Keep up the good work. I am confident that you will find this information or that it does not exist. By the way whatever happened to Scott Stringer’s audit of Success Academy after Governor Cuomo blocked the NYS Comptroller from auditing NYC charter schools?

  2. Jonathan says:

    Interesting post. Thank you for writing it. What have you got to loose by calling SA and asking? In principle you are a tax paying citizen and Success Academy likes call themselves a public school, the information you want really is public.

    • john fager says:

      Jonathan is right. Document what you know to be true that SA won’t respond to a legitimate request for information about its regents’ scores. Years ago my NYS assemblyman wanted to try to get me appointed to the Board of Regents. I told him that the UFT would never allow it and said to forget it. I wish I had let him nominate me, he was Ed Sullivan chair of the higher education committee, and then truly know who would blackball me.

  3. dms says:

    One possibility is that SA is only concerned with their 3-8 performance. The idea that they should be an ENTIRE pipeline may not enter into their world. They may view their mitzvah to the world as being able to do well for 3-8 and hand them off to other folks. No matter whether their actual outcomes in 2-3 more years are great or are regressing to the mean, their work is done. So from their point of view their fame may rest entirely on whatever happens in 3-8. Perhaps you can even call it a “whatever happens in 3-8, stays in 3-8” sort of thing. So I am not sure you can get so worked up over a measly few kids. Their model doesn’t appear to depend on it. Their model is sold based on what is happening in 3-8, so if you want to know if they are doing something special or not, I don’t think you can assay that based on 20 kids who managed to go all the way down the pipeline. I think your focus should remain on whether or not they have some secret sauce with the bulk of the kids in the network, not just a tiny subgroup of older kids. Admittedly this is a great deal for charter networks, to never have to worry about what happens to kids after they leave their middle grades.

  4. Pingback: Gary Rubinstein: The Mystery of the Missing Success Academy Regents’ Scores | Diane Ravitch's blog

  5. Georgia West says:

    Gary, I’m pretty sure that SA does not offer regents courses and does not administer regents tests. I am a middle school parent there and when I asked about regents courses in middle school I was told there weren’t any. Are you sure that charter schools have to give them? Maybe they’re like Beacon School & other district schools that have a waiver?

    • garyrubinstein says:

      Yes, I’ve learned that you are right. You should ask the school what benefit it is to your child for him or her to not have the option of taking the Regents exams in high school (some 8th graders take the Algebra I Regents also). My sense is that it could be a disadvantage in getting into college also as your child competes against students who have Regents diplomas and Advanced Regents diplomas. I think this is one of those cases where the needs of the adults is outweighing the needs of the kids.

      Do you find that at the school there is someone you can express concerns like this to?

      • Georgia West says:

        I did express my concern to Eva at a meeting – not because I am worried about how colleges view regents diplomas (obviously that is a non-issue if students are taking and doing well on AP courses – e.g. there is no disadvantage for Beacon & private school students) but because i didn’t want my child to have to take all the regents courses as public HS student. Her response was that the SA students would be well prepared to take & pass any regents tests (and indeed, my SA fifth grader seems to be covering the same earth science content — maybe even more in depth — that my 8th grader is covering in a regents earth science course). My sense is that she — like many educators I know (indeed I thought this was the standard sentiment until I saw all the “outrage” on social media that she is not doing Regents courses) — is not a fan of the Regents curricula and doesn’t want to be tied down by them. On the other hand, I think she is super focused on APs and wants 100% pass rates on those – so HS curriculum may be very test driven in that regard. Don’t know if AP data are public or if her HS students have taken any yet.

      • garyrubinstein says:

        Thanks for all this context. You know I have nothing against any families that choose to send their kids to Success Academy. Whatever Moskowitz tells you is the reason that the high school students don’t take the Regents, I’m pretty sure it is just spin. That is why people are making such a big deal out of this. They currently have 15 or so 11th graders who were once 80 1st graders years ago. Are those 11th graders now taking AP courses? Does anyone even know?

        It would be great if from time to time you could provide updates about how things are going for you at Success Academy.

  6. Pingback: Success Academy High School Students Do Not Take Regents Exams | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

  7. Pingback: Ed News, Tuesday, December 13, 2016 Edition | tigersteach

  8. Georgia West says:

    But i have not done a full investigation – e.g., maybe you can’t take regents exams if you haven’t first completed the course?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s